Amazon Fresh, Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 Oz (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary)

I've tried a lot of peanut butters, and this one is pretty solid overall. It has a rich, nutty flavor and a super creamy texture that spreads easily on toast or crackers. Great for sandwiches and even works well in baking. However, I did notice it separates a bit more than I’d like—there’s usually a layer of oil on top that needs to be stirred in. Also, it’s slightly saltier than I expected. Still, it’s a good value for the price and definitely better than many store brands. I’d buy it again, just with a quick stir first.

I didn't do a side by side taste test, but based upon my recollection this seems to be at least as good as Skippy (yeah, I know - low bar), and in the ballpark of better brands. This is mass produced, smooth peanut butter, so you should know what you're getting. It's smooth (no stirring needed) and it has some of sugar added. You should compare it with similar products. Don't complain because you're getting a different experience from the gritty, oily goop your local Whole Foods is offering; that's not what you're signing up for here. This is macro-brew peanut butter for the masses. The price seems to be very competitive, so it seems like a good value for what it is.UPDATE:After a year of supply chain issues, I finally got a chance to do a side by side taste test with this peanut butter vs. Jif. Jif seems to be widely regarded as the best mass-produced peanut butter, so this seemed like a worthwhile comparison.My taste test involved both eating straight peanut butter with a spoon (Don’t judge!), and on Carr’s table water crackers. Of course, I tasted with a fine Cabernet Sauvignon.Straight from the spoon, the Jif had a very smooth texture, while the Happy Belly was notably gritty and pasty in comparison. On a cracker this difference was imperceptible. Both had a strong and enjoyable peanut taste. Jif had a roasted peanut aftertaste that gave it a superior flavor profile, but this difference stands out primarily in side-by-side comparisons. You likely wouldn’t miss it otherwise.Bottom line: For the price, it’s hard to beat this peanut butter. You can serve it at wine tastings with Cabernet Sauvignon. You can spread it on toast. You can use it as ballast for your trans-oceanic sail. You can hurl it from parapets at invading armies. You can use jars of it as chips in your weekend poker games. You can feed it to your dog. You can feed it to your family. You can juggle jars of it in your side show performance for the circus. You can use it as a replacement for the softball at your firm’s weekend softball game (warning: you might be covered with peanut butter). You can use it for skeet shooting practice. You can use it for caulking in your bathroom or submarine. You can use it as a substitute for C4 on you next secret mission (caveat: may not actually explode). You could use it to stock your bunker. You can use it to deliver a child (caveat: this involves leaving the peanut butter in your glove box and calling a doctor). You can launch it into space (rocket not included).

Good when compared to brands like Skippy or Jif. Recommend for basic use. Fair priced.

I really love peanut butter. Love it on a spoon out of the jar, on a pb&j of course and I love them in cookies and on a banana or anything else. This peanut butter is surprisingly good. I expected it to be like some generic brands but it isn’t, it’s really tasty. And, iits not super expensive. Pictured is Amazon peanut butter on banana and on a two bite brownie which is really a one bite brownie. Just terrific. I’ll be ordering this again.

Creamy and delicious.Great taste and its easy to spread

I like the flavor and price - but wasn't prepared for the big gooey chunks in my mouth when I got beyond the top layer! Not crunchy - but soggy hunks of peanuts (I hope it's peanuts) and not just a few - but I lot. I went back and checked the reviews and saw that other customers experienced this also. If the product desccription or label said something about it not being purely creamy, the unexpected smooshy lumps in my mouth might not have grossed me out.Anyway - I like both crunchy and smooth peanut butter - but not so much the hunks of soggy lumps.

Better price then others taste better to . I been switching from local to Amazon due to having to visit local stores frequently it's stressful looking for sales .creamy flavorful not alot of oil .

This peanut butter is wonderfully creamy with a rich, nutty flavor that’s perfect for sandwiches, baking, or just eating by the spoonful. It spreads easily and has a great consistency without being too thick. I also appreciate that it uses simple ingredients with no added sugars or preservatives. However, the natural oil separation is a bit of a hassle, requiring stirring each time before use, which can be messy. The jar could also be a bit larger for the price. Overall, it's a delicious and high-quality peanut butter if you don’t mind stirring and a bit of extra effort to mix!