Maybelline New York Ultra-Liner Liquid Liner, Waterproof, Black 135L-01 , 0.25 fl oz (7.3 ml)

I really wish Maybelline would continue producing this eyeliner. I'm extremely disappointed in the brand for taking it off the market.....

Waterproof liner the best

Great liner!

As a former make up artist, I've tried countless, liquid liners, but this one is always my go to for many reasons. I hope they never discontinue this product.PROS:1.) Deep pigment.2.) Truly waterproof.3.) A nice brush instead of a pen gives better control of the line.4.) Doesn't flake, peel, or smear.5.) Stays on in all weather and conditions until you take it off.6.) Good price.7. Comes off with baby shampoo, which is the only thing I wash my face with.CONS:1.) They need to offer a true brown and charcoal as they once did, or a deep taupe. The dark brown looks black, and it's a bit harsh if you aren't young.

If you find this helpful please click the helpful button below :)I agree with the original review reposted below and add:This always stay liquid and goes on like latex so that it DOES NOT BUDGE. It always has a very pigmented line and it dries fast. I also found that with its brush applicator the gel formulation goes on thick enough that you get a solid clean line the first time with no need to touch up. And I have keep one in my car and even on the hot days it does not melt, or become thinner like the other liquid eyeliners I have used. I repurchase this every time! It is my goto liner. A DEFINITE MUST BEST EYELINER OUT THEREORIGINAL REVIEWSo I’ve been doing winged liner since I was an angsty 16 year old NIN loving black wedding dress wearing goth girl. I’m 43 now (I’ll leave the math for you) still rocking the wings and cat eyes, and while some things, like my choice of eyeliner design have stayed the same, others have apparently changed for the worse. I’m talking to you Mabelline ultra liner. What happened to you?I was so excited to put this on subscribe and save so that I could be even more antisocial than I already am, when it arrived, I was beyond disappointed. Instead of going on in the usual thick, opaque, fluid line, this was thin, smeary, and the black separated from the binding agents. I shook it up and tried again. Still messy and watery. I waited a day as if time would make it better, shook it again, and still, absolute garbage. Three days worth of having to redo my eye makeup and I was over it.Maybe this was just a bad batch, maybe it’s something else, but I love this eyeliner and it’s lasting ability (24 hours, easily removed with oil cleanser) so I’ll take myself to target and buy one there to see if it’s just the ones from Amazon. However, I won’t waste my money (or my Mama Pat eyeshadows) on this one again.My favorite next best thing is the eyeliner pen from Eyeko.

It's hard to find a good liquid eyeliner and I've used this one for years, in the black. And I'm not sure why but it's been sold out or discontinued for some reason...I tried some that are similar and none of them compare to this one. PLEASE PLEASE try to get more of these in stock in the black color, if possible! This one is my absolute favorite!!

i bought this because it was about 6 dollars cheaper than my usual eyeliner and i was trying to save money for the holidays. my only complaints are the applicator (it’s difficult to get a super sharp wing with it because the applicator doesn’t have a point and it’s also very flismy, i prefer firmer applicators for control) i took the applicator from my favorite eyeliner and dipped it into this one so it’s not a big deal i guess. another thing, it STAYS. that’s not entirely a great thing because it’s impossible to get it off with the makeup wipes i have. luckily, i have this cleansing balm that gets it off pretty good if i rub my eyes really hard, but there’s usually a piece or two that sticks to my eyelashes for a day or two. it’s not the greatest eyeliner but it holds up and looks good (if you use a different applicator) the consistency is also pretty sticky/tacky and you can definitely feel it’s there. i probably wouldn’t buy this again, but it’s still worth a try if you like eyeliner that won’t come off and overly flexible applicators. this just isn’t for me

I love this product, however, THIS IS NOT WHAT YOU WILL RECEIVE. They send you the latest version which is very disappointing.